Why? There are lots of dangers in handling molten metals of course, but as far as I can see, the increased risk with this is mainly around having molten metal inside a plastic cavity. It could lead a fire with noxious fumes. Not that that isn't serious, but its not a RF issue. It's also mitigated by the extremely high temps silicon carbide can handle and that the heated bit is inside a ceramic cocoon. There is also danger in the dust from various materials that shouldn't ignored but is easy to protect against.
I don't have any particular expertise on the subject Mike. Call it instinct or the product of too many bad outcomes doing too many things nobody else does that went bad.
Here is what I said:
It really is amazing, even mind blowing, and MAYBE it's even ok..... But every neuron in my brain says it's not ok and it's a disaster waiting to happen. Maybe if it became common practice, and maybe if a microwave engineer endorsed it, I'd change my mind. But for the time being, I'm not doing it nor am I blessing it or endorsing it.
That didn't speak to any expertise. I even went so far as to say "
MAYBE it's even ok".
I also said "maybe if a microwave engineer endorsed it, I'd change my mind."
Basically, it strikes me as one of those daring things people do and don't get hurt...... Until they do.
It certainly isn't as inherently safe as watching the sunset. Nor even cautiously dangerous like carefully handling a sharp knife, or lighting a bbq, or driving in heavy traffic, or calling your wife stupid. We all know those things have risks, but we do them anyway because experience tells us that the odds of getting hurt are low enough to be worth it.
For me, melting metal in a microwave is an unknown risk. Molten metal is inherently dangerous enough (as you acknowledged) without doing it using a process only ever done once by an unknown youtube actor under
REALLY sketchy conditions.
I confess that your additional research makes me feel a bit better, but not sufficiently better to make it feel normal for me.
Frankly, I do all kinds of things I would never suggest that others do. This kind of fits that mold. It's something that might be ok for those that understand it or have the required expertise. But I don't fit that description and I don't think many of us hobby machinists do.
It's too big an unknown for me. For example, have you ever boiled a cup of water in the microwave that ended up superheating the water? Everything looks good until you bounce the cup on the counter. Then suddenly the water flash boils and sprays boiling water everywhere! Could that happen to metal? Who has researched that? What other unknown processes exist with microwaved metal? I get the heated crucible thing but how do we know there is no direct absorption? Why can't the metal act like an antenna? Maybe the wrong shape can!
You asked why I'm so cautious? As described above, the problem is that I don't know what could go wrong. I don't know enough to suggest possible risks. I don't even know enough to know what I don't know. And that's what stops me cold.