-
Scam Alert. Members are reminded to NOT send money to buy anything. Don't buy things remote and have it shipped - go get it yourself, pay in person, and take your equipment with you. Scammers have burned people on this forum. Urgency, secrecy, excuses, selling for friend, newish members, FUD, are RED FLAGS. A video conference call is not adequate assurance. Face to face interactions are required. Please report suspicions to the forum admins. Stay Safe - anyone can get scammed.
Tips/Techniques Unique uses for ball bearings
- Thread starter Johnwa
- Start date
Tips/Techniques
Matt-Aburg
Ultra Member
That is sweet. I would think you could figure out exactly how much compression to get exact size. It probably adds surface hardness also... Goodbye emery paper !!
I bet it would.
I'd love to see a high magnification video of what is happening under that ball.....
Would have to be reducing the diameter right?
Can’t find a macro video, but here’s some numbers:
My math says dimensions won’t change much. 125uRa roughness is pretty gross, and if the cogsdill description is accurate, smoothing out a 125uRa machining finish would squish down the peaks and fill in the valleys, so maybe reduce the O.D. of a cylindrical piece by half of the Ra value. 62 millionths of an inch?
Matt-Aburg
Ultra Member
Oh that’s way less than I expected.
Thanks!
I don't really think it would be much of anything. The only reduction would be associated with the surface roughness peaks normalizing to the average by filling in the valleys. That won't be 100%, but I'd still expect that to be the trend.
Edit - didn't see @whydontu 's post till after posting the above. I agree with his comments.
Fundamentally, you can't compress the bar. You can only even out the bumps and valleys.
Last edited:
That is awesome! I didn't know about this at all. And definitely on the to do list now! What a cool project and he is an excellent machinist.
There is a tricky bit though. The nut which holds the ball bearing captive I have a few questions... What size is the hole to keep the bearing in place? Why dosen't the bearing rub on the housing? The nut seems to cinch down to the bottom of the threads yet the ball can still move around. What might the clearance be?
Would this work on aluminium too?
@Johnwa thanks for posting this.
@johnnielsen did you use this technique?
Last edited:
Obviously I know next to nothing but it seems to me that the hole only needs to be small enough contain the steel ball
I suspect there may be washers holding the captive ball bearing in the middle of the slot?
I think the bore for the bearing needs to be close tolerance so that it’s not rattling around.
Last edited:
Not that bearing. The steel ball. definitions .... argh I don't have clear words.Obviously I know next to nothing but it seems to me that the hole only needs to be small enough contain the ball bearing.
I suspect there may be washers holding the bearing in the middle of the slot?
I think the bore for the bearing needs to be close tolerance so that it’s not rattling around.
This is a ball bearing says google:
from https://www.theengineerspost.com/types-of-bearings/
McMaster says these are steel balls.
McMaster-Carr
McMaster-Carr is the complete source for your plant with over 595,000 products. 98% of products ordered ship from stock and deliver same or next day.
Ok I'll rephrase now that I know what the names are.
Questions:
There is a tricky bit though. The nut which holds the Steel ball captive I have a few questions... What size is the hole to keep the ball in place? Why dosen't the ball rub on the housing? The nut seems to cinch down to the bottom of the threads yet the ball can still move around. What might the clearance be?
Sorry my explanation mixed metaphors or at least balls and bearingsNot that bearing. The steel ball. definitions .... argh I don't have clear words.
This is a ball bearing says google:
View attachment 41538
from https://www.theengineerspost.com/types-of-bearings/
McMaster says these are steel balls.
McMaster-Carr
McMaster-Carr is the complete source for your plant with over 595,000 products. 98% of products ordered ship from stock and deliver same or next day.www.mcmaster.com
Ok I'll rephrase now that I know what the names are.
Questions:
There is a tricky bit though. The nut which holds the Steel ball captive I have a few questions... What size is the hole to keep the ball in place? Why dosen't the ball rub on the housing? The nut seems to cinch down to the bottom of the threads yet the ball can still move around. What might the clearance be?
Ironman
Ultra Member
I think there is nothing critical here. The ball is captured by the end cap and the ball bearing behind it takes the thrust pressure. He never gave dimensions because it will depend on the size of the ball and the ball bearing size will depend on the size of your tool post slot. Actually you could let the ball bearing hang out each side as well.
I find myself wondering if a simple knurling tool wouldn't do exactly the same thing. Just replace the knurling wheels with smooth curved surfaces..... Not flat. Could be one or two wheels.
If they exist, a round sided bearing would be perfect!
I bet this process is really hard on the cross-slide screw and nut. Not something I'd want to do very often. I like my lathe too much to do that to it.
Also thinking that I wouldn't use that without a follow rest.
I recently received and tried some round Inserts for cutting Aluminium. I was blown away by the improved finish on hot-rolled steel. I have more experimenting to do but for right now I'm just plain amazed.
If they exist, a round sided bearing would be perfect!
I bet this process is really hard on the cross-slide screw and nut. Not something I'd want to do very often. I like my lathe too much to do that to it.
Also thinking that I wouldn't use that without a follow rest.
I recently received and tried some round Inserts for cutting Aluminium. I was blown away by the improved finish on hot-rolled steel. I have more experimenting to do but for right now I'm just plain amazed.
That’s what I found when I just for laughs and giggles tried one out a long time ago; actually I was too lazy to change the insert back to steel after working in ALU. I only had one tool holder at the time…
If you try inserts for SS on hot rolled steel, you will also see an improvement vs a regular steel insert (when taking light cuts).
I am not sure about that: depending on the ball size, there is a very small contact area that does the work. I would be surprised if the forces are any higher than during regular medium to heavy turning.
As far as using a knurling tool with two crowned, smooth wheels: that should work perfectly. The forces would be larger than using just a ball because of the larger contact area.
That's where I started too. It is good to question these things.
Isn't the balls working area strictly determined by its diameter? And wouldn't a torrus of the same major diameter have a much smaller working area because of the much smaller cylinder radius?
Edit - above torrus description revised for clarity.
Last edited: